Supreme Court upholds offensive trademarks as form of free speech
Jun 20, 2017, 00:08
The Supreme Court ruled Monday that a law that prohibits the government from registering trademarks that "disparage" others violates the First Amendment, a decision that could impact the Washington Redskins' efforts to hang on to its controversial name.
The Supreme Courtdecided that the US Patent and Trademark Office could not refuse the Portland, Oregon-based band the right to trademark the name, generally seen as a racial slur on Asians but which the group's founder, Simon Tam, had said was an act of "re-appropriation".
The band's victory could be welcome news for the Washington Redskins, which has been waging its own legal fight over the team's name, which some people find offensive.
The case was being closely watched because the Washington Redskins had asked the court to take its case challenging the PTO's decision to cancel its trademark, but the court refused. She said the nickname is a racist slur that never should have been trademarked in the first place. Among them is a 64-page brief filed by Pro-Football Inc., piggybacking The Slants case for the Washington Redskins' NFL team, which lost its trademark protection because the team name was considered disparaging.
The justices were unanimous in saying that the 71-year-old trademark law barring disparaging terms infringes free speech rights guaranteed in the Constitution's First Amendment.
When the government grants a trademark to a business owner, the owner gains the exclusive legal right to use the name on products and merchandise such as T-shirts. Such suits must be filed by the federal government, not private citizens, that court held.
Band says decision means "marginalized communities" can determine for themselves what's best, even if it involves words thought racially insensitive. Alito also said trademarks are not immune from First Amendment protection as part of a government program or subsidy.
"I am THRILLED!" he said in a statement Monday morning.
With today's ruling onLee v. Tam (known now as Matal v. Tam), the court overturned a provision that is part of the Lanham Act, which that disallowed terms or phrases that "may disparage" persons from receiving federal trademark registration.
The court also said the Voting Rights Act provision at issue could only be enforced by the USA attorney general, and lawsuits by private parties were barred.
Justice Neil Gorsuch joined the court after arguments were heard in the case and did not participate in Monday's decision. He sought to register the name with the trademark office. The band's lawyers argued that the government can not use trademark law to impose burdens on free speech to protect listeners from offense.
DUP leader Arlene Foster insisted that any deal with the Conservatives would not undermine the province's peace accords. However, a soft Brexit would be a "daft" option, a political analyst told CNBC on Wednesday.
Apple is facing some serious competition from the likes of tech rivals Amazon and Google in the race for voice-powered computing. Apple wants to combine the two categories in one device and has price the HomePod accordingly.
He was detained when as tour group prepared to leave North Korea, charged with engaging in allegedly anti-state activity. The State Department continues to "have discussions" with North Korea about the release of other Americans jailed there.
Gary Locke, a former USA ambassador to China, has said that North Korea uses Americans in detention as "bargaining chips". The Ohio hospital where Otto was taken has said that he is in stable condition but suffered "severe neurological injury".
Only way it can ruin boxing is if McGregor goes and boxes Floyd because he's going to look really ridiculous boxing him. The current odds mean that you would have to bet $800 on Mayweather just to get $100 in profit if you win.
Zabihullah Mujahid, a spokesman for the Taliban, wrote in a WhatsApp message that the attacker was a Taliban infiltrator. A White House spokesman said Trump was "following the emerging situation in Afghanistan" where the soldiers were killed.
The Italian club's fifth successive Champions League final defeat may have ended Buffon's hopes of winning the competition. Real Madrid is the first team since the late 80's with AC Milan to win consecutive Champions League .
Likewise, three police personnel and a paramilitary trooper were wounded in a grenade attack in Srinagar on Sunday night. A CRPF camp at Padgampora in Pulwama too came under attack. "Searches in the area are presently on", said Yadav.
With the DUP providing the Conservatives a narrow, but crucial, majority in Parliament, it could have an outsized influence. The current leader of the DUP is Arlene Foster . "Just to be clear, we will act in the national interest".
Wind howling as final round at Erin Hills gets under way
The course had been softened by rain earlier in the week, and it finally played the way the USGA wanted in the final round. The world No. 13 stuffed his 310-yard approach shot to within 8 feet on the par-5 that stretches well beyond 600 yards.
More than 20 dead from forest fires in central Portugal
The Associated Press, citing Portuguese media, reports that investigators trace the cause to a "dry thunderstorm". The forest fires are the worst to have hit Portugal since 1966, when 25 soldiers died fighting several blazes.
Darjeeling unrest leaves 36 policemen injured
The Court also directed the Bengal government to take immediate steps to restore peace and normalcy in the hills. He had, however, said that one person had died on Saturday, but did not specify the cause of his death.
Wife: Man who shot congressman wanted to work on tax policy
When he left, she said, Hodgkinson told her he was going to Washington , D.C.to "work with people to change the tax brackets". Here's what she said. "He said, 'I understand, ' and said he needed to take the gun to a range to shoot it, Watson said.
Georgia jobless rate drops to 4.9 percent in May
OC in added a net 3,800 jobs year-over-year, led by 3,700 in construction and 3,100 in professional and business services. The number of people counted as unemployed also dropped, by 660 from a month ago and more than 2,800 from a year ago.
Wallenda to discuss hanging by teeth over Niagara Falls
A fall from that height would mean certain death, but Wallenda wore a safety tether to comply with New York State labor law. If you want to come see the stunt in person, you're encouraged to arrive no later than 8:15 a.m.
London tower fire: What do we know?
Michael Paramasivan said he was watching TV in the building as his girlfriend and daughter slept when he smelled burning plastic. Ambulance officials say 78 people were being treated in hospitals across London for a range of injuries and smoke inhalation.
La Decima for Rafael Nadal at French Open 2017
Wawrinka, who triumphed in Geneva in the buildup to the tournament, had also won a career-high 11 successive matches on clay. Sometimes it is too short of a time and I really can't recover fast enough. "He's playing the best he's ever played".
Alexis Sanchez agrees to Manchester City move
The report claims that the Chilean has provisionally agreed to a new three-year deal with the Gunners at £280,000-a-week wages. Sanchez has scored 72 goals in 144 appearances in all competitions since joining Arsenal from Barca in 2014.
Accuser gives emotional testimony in Cosby trial
A retired mother of two who has been married to the same man for 47 years, Gianni cut an unassuming figure on the stand. Constand was direct and polite under cross-examination, even when Agrusa's questioning grew pointed and accusatory.
WWDC 2017: Apple introduces smart compact music speaker
Google , meanwhile, previewed new speaker features such as hands-free phone calling during its software conference last month. The HomePod features seven tweeters and a 4-inch woofer that Apple suggests will provide sound that will "rock the house".