Supreme Court upholds offensive trademarks as form of free speech

Jun 20, 2017, 00:08

The Supreme Court ruled Monday that a law that prohibits the government from registering trademarks that "disparage" others violates the First Amendment, a decision that could impact the Washington Redskins' efforts to hang on to its controversial name.

The Supreme Court decided that the US Patent and Trademark Office could not refuse the Portland, Oregon-based band the right to trademark the name, generally seen as a racial slur on Asians but which the group's founder, Simon Tam, had said was an act of "re-appropriation".

The band's victory could be welcome news for the Washington Redskins, which has been waging its own legal fight over the team's name, which some people find offensive.

The case was being closely watched because the Washington Redskins had asked the court to take its case challenging the PTO's decision to cancel its trademark, but the court refused. She said the nickname is a racist slur that never should have been trademarked in the first place. Among them is a 64-page brief filed by Pro-Football Inc., piggybacking The Slants case for the Washington Redskins' NFL team, which lost its trademark protection because the team name was considered disparaging.

More news: Trump gives remarks on ballfield shooting

The justices were unanimous in saying that the 71-year-old trademark law barring disparaging terms infringes free speech rights guaranteed in the Constitution's First Amendment.

When the government grants a trademark to a business owner, the owner gains the exclusive legal right to use the name on products and merchandise such as T-shirts. Such suits must be filed by the federal government, not private citizens, that court held.

Band says decision means "marginalized communities" can determine for themselves what's best, even if it involves words thought racially insensitive. Alito also said trademarks are not immune from First Amendment protection as part of a government program or subsidy.

"It canceled the registration for the Washington Redskins in 2014 at the behest of some Native Americans who considered the name offensive".

More news: Final Fantasy 15 Monster of the Deep DLC Teased

"I am THRILLED!" he said in a statement Monday morning.

With today's ruling on Lee v. Tam (known now as Matal v. Tam), the court overturned a provision that is part of the Lanham Act, which that disallowed terms or phrases that "may disparage" persons from receiving federal trademark registration.

The court also said the Voting Rights Act provision at issue could only be enforced by the USA attorney general, and lawsuits by private parties were barred.

Justice Neil Gorsuch joined the court after arguments were heard in the case and did not participate in Monday's decision. He sought to register the name with the trademark office. The band's lawyers argued that the government can not use trademark law to impose burdens on free speech to protect listeners from offense.

More news: Seahawks' RB Eddie Lacy hits second weight clause marker

Loading...
loading...
loading...
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
  • Obama-Era Plan for Undocumented Parents Rescinded by the US

    Obama-Era Plan for Undocumented Parents Rescinded by the US

    These protections were extended to Dreamers by the 2012 Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program. One of the benefits DACA has provided Ibarra is being able to move freely across the country.
    Brexit negotiations to go ahead on Monday, Government confirms

    Brexit negotiations to go ahead on Monday, Government confirms

    DUP leader Arlene Foster insisted that any deal with the Conservatives would not undermine the province's peace accords. However, a soft Brexit would be a "daft" option, a political analyst told CNBC on Wednesday.

    Heritage praises Trump's plans for air traffic control

    Jerry Moran, R-Kan., said the plan was likely to raise costs for consumers and hurt small airports. And lawmakers are uneasy about giving regulatory authority to a private organization.
  • Siri in your living room: Apple unveils $349 HomePod

    Apple is facing some serious competition from the likes of tech rivals Amazon and Google in the race for voice-powered computing. Apple wants to combine the two categories in one device and has price the HomePod accordingly.
    North Korea releases US citizen Otto Warmbier

    North Korea releases US citizen Otto Warmbier

    He was detained when as tour group prepared to leave North Korea, charged with engaging in allegedly anti-state activity. The State Department continues to "have discussions" with North Korea about the release of other Americans jailed there.

    Warriors' Green stays in Game 4 after technical foul fiasco

    Iman Shumpert and Zaza Pachulia went to the floor in a scrum and Pachulia appeared to hit the wingman in the groin. Babers-Green was seen being held back by a friend of Green's.
  • US official's 'quiet diplomacy' led to Warmbier's release

    Gary Locke, a former USA ambassador to China, has said that North Korea uses Americans in detention as "bargaining chips". The Ohio hospital where Otto was taken has said that he is in stable condition but suffered "severe neurological injury".

    Floyd Mayweather Opens as Heavy Betting Favorite Over Conor McGregor

    Only way it can ruin boxing is if McGregor goes and boxes Floyd because he's going to look really ridiculous boxing him. The current odds mean that you would have to bet $800 on Mayweather just to get $100 in profit if you win.

    At Least 3 US Soldiers Killed In 'Insider Attack' In Afghanistan

    Zabihullah Mujahid, a spokesman for the Taliban, wrote in a WhatsApp message that the attacker was a Taliban infiltrator. A White House spokesman said Trump was "following the emerging situation in Afghanistan" where the soldiers were killed.
  • Luka Modric believes Real Madrid will dominate European football for some time

    Luka Modric believes Real Madrid will dominate European football for some time

    The Italian club's fifth successive Champions League final defeat may have ended Buffon's hopes of winning the competition. Real Madrid is the first team since the late 80's with AC Milan to win consecutive Champions League .
    CRPF soldiers injured in Tral grenade attack

    CRPF soldiers injured in Tral grenade attack

    Likewise, three police personnel and a paramilitary trooper were wounded in a grenade attack in Srinagar on Sunday night. A CRPF camp at Padgampora in Pulwama too came under attack. "Searches in the area are presently on", said Yadav.

    DUP to support minority Tory government after 'confidence and supply' deal reached

    With the DUP providing the Conservatives a narrow, but crucial, majority in Parliament, it could have an outsized influence. The current leader of the DUP is Arlene Foster . "Just to be clear, we will act in the national interest".
popular