Justices won't hear case of anti-gay marriage florist

Jun 28, 2018, 00:52
Justices won't hear case of anti-gay marriage florist

Stutzman, a Washington state florist, was offered multiple opportunities to settle her case by state and local prosecutors but repeatedly refused. Although the florist's lawyers assert that there was hostility to her religious beliefs from the fact that the state enforced its nondiscrimination law, there is no evidence of hostility towards religious beliefs in the case. "The Washington attorney general's efforts to punish her because he dislikes her beliefs about marriage are as impermissible as Colorado's attempt to punish Jack Phillips and Masterpiece Cakeshop". The Supreme Court on Monday, June 25, 2018, ordered Washington courts to take a new look at Stutzman's case because of her religious objection to same-sex marriage.

The Supreme Court put on hold the lower court's order that a new map be drawn, leaving the Republican-drawn districts in place for congressional elections in November, giving a boost to Republicans in their bid to maintain control of the U.S. House of Representatives. "The two sued Stutzman after she declined, because of her faith, to design custom floral arrangements celebrating the same-sex wedding of a customer she had served for almost ten years".

The case was set to finally decide whether state anti-discrimination laws violate the Constitutional right to free speech - the store's owner claimed that creating the arrangement would force her to endorse something she has religious convictions against.

In a fiery dissent, Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote that the ruling "means that, after years of litigation and undeniable proof of intentional discrimination, minority voters in Texas - despite constituting a majority of the population within the state - will continue to be under-represented in the political process".

More news: Lewis Hamilton wins French Grand Prix to retake F1 lead

There was no apparent reason to send the case back instead of just denying review, which would have allowed the state supreme court's decision to stand.

On the surface, the North Carolina case doesn't appear to have the same problem the high court identified in the Wisconsin lawsuit.

Associate law professor Jim Oleske at Lewis and Clark Law School talked to Colorado Matters about the impact of Masterpiece on the Arlene's Flowers case, and where it goes from here.

In Masterpiece Cakeshop, the high court said that the Colorado Civil Rights Commission had shown hostility toward the baker's religious beliefs in ruling that he had violated the state's anti-discrimination laws when he refused to make the cake. "This case is no more about access to flowers than civil rights cases in the 1960s were about access to sandwiches", the court said, quoting from the plaintiffs' brief.

More news: Summer solstice 2018: The longest day in pictures

A bitterly divided Supreme Court handed down its decision in a redistricting case today.

Democratic Washington Gov. Jay Inslee echoed a similar sentiment in a press release of his own. Stutzman said that providing the service would be a violation of her faith.

Some of the nation's most controversially drawn legislative districts will remain as they are through the midterm elections - and potentially into the 2020 races - after the U.S. Supreme Court slapped down racial gerrymandering challenges to three Texas districts and punted on a partisan gerrymandering case for the third time this month.

More news: Proposal to split California into three states qualifies for November ballot

Loading...
loading...
loading...
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
  • Federal Bureau of Investigation  report: Anti-Trump texts 'cast a cloud' over email probe

    Federal Bureau of Investigation report: Anti-Trump texts 'cast a cloud' over email probe

    The FBI obtained a warrant nine days before the presidential election to review those emails, found on the laptop of former Rep. He also quoted lawyer and Fox News talking head Mark Levin, who said " Donald Trump was 100% right to fire James Comey ".
    Pakistan to celebrate Eidul Fitr on Saturday

    Pakistan to celebrate Eidul Fitr on Saturday

    The observance begins the morning after the crescent moon is visibly sighted, marking the beginning of the new month. The moon sighting committee under the Islamic Foundation decides when Eid-ul-Fitr will be celebrated in Bangladesh.
    Kilauea Volcano Still Erupting; More Than 600 Homes Destroyed

    Kilauea Volcano Still Erupting; More Than 600 Homes Destroyed

    Officials warned that gas emissions from Fissure 8 have doubled triggering air quality concerns, according to Hawaii News Now . A small explosion on the summit of Kilauea volcano has triggered an quake but there are no reports of damage.
  • Saudi officers hand out roses to women drivers in historic moment

    Saudi officers hand out roses to women drivers in historic moment

    Earlier this month, Saudi Arabia issued its first driver's licenses to 10 women who already had licenses from other countries. Saudi law enforces a strict form of Sunni Islam known as Wahhabism and is known for its gender segregation rules.
    Aguero leads the line again for Argentina v Croatia

    Aguero leads the line again for Argentina v Croatia

    It was a hard night for Messi and Argentina . "We are here to help him every moment, and of course we will be at his side". In Messi, Maxi Meza, Angel Di Maria and Aguero, Sampaoli arguably has the best attack at the World Cup .
    Meghan Markle Has A New In-House ‘Surprise Stylist’

    Meghan Markle Has A New In-House ‘Surprise Stylist’

    The ceremony saw the royals come out in full attendance barring the absence of Prince Philip and the youngest royal Prince Louis . The official royal tour will be a rite of passage for royal newcomer Meghan, 36, as she settles into married life with Harry, 33.
  • US Open: Phil Mickelson explains weird decision to hit a moving ball

    Then he kept on with his round and parred the most hard hole on the course, the 14th, still smiling and acknowledging fans. Open is well underway. "It's something you might see at your club with your mates". "I think he just snapped".
    Supreme Court gives OK to states to clean voting rolls

    Supreme Court gives OK to states to clean voting rolls

    The SCOTUS ruling wasn't limited to the Buckeye State, as a handful of other states follow the voter purge act as well. The ruling was 5-4, with the court's conservative justices in the majority, while the four liberal justices dissented.
    Porsche Picks Taycan as Name for Its First Electric Vehicle

    Porsche Picks Taycan as Name for Its First Electric Vehicle

    This will enable 0-100km/h acceleration in "well under 3.5 seconds", Porsche says, with 0-200km/h coming up in under 12 seconds. With the lack of charging infrastructure, the chances of the Taycan coming to India anytime soon are nearly non-existent.
  • Heather Locklear arrested, accused of battery on officer, emergency personnel

    Heather Locklear arrested, accused of battery on officer, emergency personnel

    The 56-year-old actress was among the biggest television stars of the 1980s and 1990s, with roles on " Dynasty ", "T.J". The 911 call reported a disturbance at her home and when cops arrived, she appeared intoxicated and agitated.
    Tesla sues ex-employee who claims whistleblower status

    Tesla sues ex-employee who claims whistleblower status

    In a statement to Reuters , Tesla noted that the company still expects to grow its solar and battery business over time. Tesla lawyers have asked for a court order to inspect Tripp's computers, emails, online messages and phone calls.
    Trump says Kim 'trusts me, and I trust him'

    Trump says Kim 'trusts me, and I trust him'

    It appears to reflect a new confidence among officials in North Korea that the country has really been accepted onto the world stage.
popular