Supreme Court Weighs In on Unprecedented Murder Case

Jun 24, 2019, 00:38
Supreme Court Weighs In on Unprecedented Murder Case

The Supreme Court on Friday overturned the murder conviction of a Black man on the grounds that a MS district attorney intentionally kept Black jurors off the case.

"The numbers speak loudly", Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote for the majority. "In the six trials blended, the Suppose struck 41 of the 42 black doable jurors it might perchance perchance most likely perchance occupy struck". Friday's ruling applied that precedent and, Kavanaugh wrote, "we break no new legal ground".

On Friday, Thomas, joined by Neil Gorsuch, called the majority opinion "manifestly incorrect". Thomas went so far as calling for the court to junk its 1986 decision in Batson v. Kentucky, which says potential jurors can not be excluded due to their race, and lawyers must provide a nondiscriminatory explanation for striking them.

Curtis Flowers was tried six times by the same prosecutor for killing four people at a furniture store 23 years ago. And the MS high court in the 2010 case deferred to a judge's finding that Evans had nondiscriminatory reasons for striking the black jurors - because they had ties to Flowers or had been sued by Tardy Furniture, for instance.

In Mississippi, a southern state with a history of slavery and racial segregation, "I met only one white person who thought that Curtis Flowers was innocent", Baran told AFP. They said a seventh trial "would be unprecedented, and completely unwarranted given both the flimsiness of the evidence against him and the long trail of misconduct that has kept him wrongfully incarcerated all these years".

More news: Dillian Whyte: Tyson Fury Should Be 'Ashamed' Of Facing Tom Schwarz

Flowers's lawyers said that means looking at Evans's work in previous trials, not just the most recent one.

This Aug. 3, 2017 listing supplied by Mississippi Division of Corrections reveals Curtis Vegetation, who's homicide case has long gone to trial six times. Flowers was charged with executing four people inside Tardy Furniture Store in the small town of Winona, Miss., in 1996.

The first three trials were dismissed because of prosecutor misconduct and the second two ended in hung juries.

In this March 20, 2019 file photo, Attorney Sheri Johnson leaves the Supreme Court after challenging a MS prosecutor's decision to keep African-Americans off the jury in the trial of Curtis Flowers, in Washington. "Flowers presented no evidence whatsoever of purposeful race discrimination by the State".

Defense attorneys could also seek to remove Evans and state court Judge Joseph Loper from the case.

More news: Mnuchin: Trump could ease restrictions on Huawei if trade talks advance

"Any competent prosecutor would have exercised the same strikes as the State did in this trial".

Multiple witnesses saw Flowers in the vicinity of the store.

The justices weighed Evans' history of striking African-American jurors. These are tough cases for states to decide when there's an old case to try to see if they have anything that they can persuade a jury that this guy is guilty. As a result, two black jurors were seated, and the juries deadlocked.

"The Constitution forbids striking even a single prospective juror for a discriminatory objective", Kavanaugh said. "We simply enforce and reinforce Batson by applying it to the extraordinary facts of this case".

Thomas spent much of the important section of his conception questioning why his colleagues took the case within the important rep 22 situation - to illustrate, citing the "dazzling quantity of media attention" surrounding the case. A jailhouse informant who claimed Flowers had confessed to him recanted in recorded telephone conversations with American Public Media's "In the Dark" podcast. The Mississippi Supreme Court affirmed the conviction. The dissenters here were Justice Thomas and Justice Gorsuch. "Although the court's opinion might boost its self-esteem, it also needlessly prolongs the suffering of four victims' families", he wrote.

More news: China to release details on blacklist of 'unreliable' companies soon

Loading...
loading...
loading...
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
  • The New York Knicks Have Traded Up To Nab Michigan's Ignas Brazdeikis

    The New York Knicks Have Traded Up To Nab Michigan's Ignas Brazdeikis

    Canada's record for most players taken in the draft was set in 2014 when four were selected, including three in the first round. Barrett with the No. 3 overall pick, the recent workouts have led to speculation that they may be looking to trade down.
    Golden State congratulates Raptors on National Basketball Association  title with full-page newspaper ad

    Golden State congratulates Raptors on National Basketball Association title with full-page newspaper ad

    The city has opened viewing of the rally at Yonge-Dundas Square, along with Coronation Park on the lakefront as alternatives. As the saying goes, act like you've been there before, and the Golden State Warriors certainly know how to do it.
    Ross Taylor Prepares for India v New Zealand

    Ross Taylor Prepares for India v New Zealand

    Nottingham Weather Updates Live: Hour by Hour Rain Forecast Ahead of India vs New Zealand CWC 2019 Match at Trent Bridge . Team physio Patrick Farhart is assessing Dhawan's injury after the batsman was taken to Leeds for detailed scans.
  • Gloria Vanderbilt Dead: Son Anderson Cooper Delivers Tribute

    Gloria Vanderbilt Dead: Son Anderson Cooper Delivers Tribute

    As a designer, she was well known for her signature stylish jeans that were highly sought after in the 1970s and '80s. The trial around who would take control of young Vanderbilt's life and finances was a tabloid sensation at the time.
    Blackout across Argentina and Uruguay leaves tens of millions in the dark

    Blackout across Argentina and Uruguay leaves tens of millions in the dark

    Since taking office, Macri has said that gradual austerity measures were needed to revive the country's struggling economy. Downtown Buenos Aires during the power cut that left nearly all of Argentina and Uruguay without electricity.
    German minister upbeat on Iran trade vehicle before Rouhani talks

    German minister upbeat on Iran trade vehicle before Rouhani talks

    Mohammad Javad Zarif said on Monday that the US "cannot expect to stay safe" after launching its economic war. Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif speaks during a news conference in Baghdad, Iraq, May 26, 2019.
  • YouTuber buys MI  town and calls it Gay Hell to protest Trump

    YouTuber buys MI town and calls it Gay Hell to protest Trump

    Daniel then clarified his flag rule is intended as a joke and there will not be a ban on other flags, Daniel told NBC News. The YouTuber told CNN that the move was a way of "getting my audience involved in politics by doing it in a amusing way".
    Mexico publishes Trump's 'secret deal' on migration

    Mexico publishes Trump's 'secret deal' on migration

    Although this will not permanently solve illegal immigration in the United States , this will help minimize the entry of new ones. The document adds that the agreement would be "part of a regional approach" to dealing with undocumented migrants and refugees.

    'He Had a Gun Drawn': Parents Arrested With 2 Young Children

    Horne said the parents didn't know their daughter had taken the doll until they were in the vehicle leaving the store. That woman was detained by the officer, who learned she had three misdemeanor warrants for her arrest, police said.
  • 4m Trump launches 2020 re-election campaign

    4m Trump launches 2020 re-election campaign

    Biden, though, has faced criticism among Democratic rivals for his embrace of high-rolling donors and top-dollar fundraisers. His new campaign slogan - "Keep America Great" - was greeted with boisterous cheers.

    New Video Shows Gunman Stalking David Oritz Before Walking Up & Shooting Him

    The alleged assailants had been paid 400,000 Dominican pesos, or just under $8,000, to kill Ortiz, according to Police Maj. In a statement provided by the Red Sox , Tiffany Ortiz said that David Ortiz was "making good progress towards recovery".
    Palace identify Aarons as a potential replacement for Wan-Bissaka

    Palace identify Aarons as a potential replacement for Wan-Bissaka

    According to the Guardian , United have now had an offer "in excess of £40m" turned down. Statistically, Aarons has had a better season than Wan-Bissaka.
popular